Skip to content

An American Eatery Since 1896

Oyster Bay

107 South St.Oyster Bay, NY 11771(516) 922-9293

Celebrations & Events

Treat your guests to a top notch dinning experience. We can accommodate any size party in one of our newly renovated private catering rooms or outdoor spaces. Contact Us For Details

Lunch & Dinner

Stop in for Lunch or Dinner 7 Days a Week.
See Our Menu

Private Catering

Perfect for Corporate Events or Any Special Occasion.Contact Us To Make Reservations

Welcome Back

Indoor Dining Is Now Open In All Locations
inside2

Private
Catering
Available

Perfect for Corporate Events
or Any Special Occasion.

about us

We Serve Our GuestsLike Family

When we first took ownership of our historic restaurant in Oyster Bay we made a commitment to ourselves and our customers that we would treat every person that comes through the door as if they were a guest in our home.  That every dish that leaves our kitchen is prepared with the best ingredients and with the same care that we put into Sunday dinner with
our families.
Read More >

Classic American Fare

Featured Menu Items

Our menu combines fresh ingredients and unique flavors with the traditional homestyle cooking that we have all grown to love.  




Wine & SpiritsStartersSaladsMains

  • The Homestead Wine Closet

    Featuring privately selected wines by the glass or bottle

  • Signature Cocktails

    Come try one of our signature cocktails today!

  • Over 30 Beers on Tap!

    Served through our brand new state of the art tap system

  • Happy Hour Drink Specials

    Join us weekdays 4-7pm for Beer, Wine & Cocktail Specials

  • BAKED CLAMS *Voted Best on Long Island*

    Fresh Oyster Bay clams, topped with our own seasoned
    breadcrumb mix (1 Doz)

  • FRIED CALAMARI

    Served with 3 dipping sauces

  • CHICKEN WINGS

    Sauces: Buffalo, Thai Chili, Teriyaki,
    Spicy Peanut, Cajun Dry Rub, Bourbon, Habanero, Honey BBQ

  • AHI TUNA TARTARE

    Served with avocado, wanton strips, and wasabi mayo

  • JUMBO BAVARIAN PRETZEL

    Served with cheese sauce & spicy mustard

  • THE HOMESTEAD

    Fresh spring mix, fresh mozzarella, sundried tomato, grape tomato, artichoke hearts, olives, roasted red peppers, gorgonzola with a homemade basil balsamic dressing

  • ASIAN SALAD

    Fresh spring mix, carrots, scallions, almonds, wonton strips in a ginger dressing

  • ARUGULA & GOAT CHEESE

    Walnuts, fennel, apples, grape tomato, olives, balsamic dressing

  • ICEBERG LETTUCE WEDGE

    Half cut wedge, applewood bacon, grape tomato, homemade garlic blue cheese dressing topped with a homemade garlic blue cheese dressing

  • COWBOY BONELESS RIB-EYE

    Dry aged Angus beef cut to order and
    char-grilled served with
    Yukon Gold Garlic Mashed Potato, Baked Potato or Home Fries

  • MARINATED SKIRT STEAK

    Dry aged Angus beef cut to order and
    char-grilled served with vegetables.
    Yukon gold garlic mashed potato or baked

  • BRAISED SHORT RIB

    Slow Roasted Short Rib, Risotto Cake

  • THE HOMESTEAD VEAL CHOP

    Pounded thin, breaded, pan fried topped with spinach, prosciutto & mozzarella in a brown sherry sauce


View Our Full Menu Here

Classic American Fare

Featured Menu Items

Our menu combines fresh ingredients and unique flavors with the traditional homestyle cooking that we have all grown to love.  





View Our Full Menu Here

Private Catering Rooms Available for Corporate Events & Celebrations


Contact Us

We would love to hear from you. Please call us or fill out the form below and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

Oyster Bay

(516) 992-9293

thehomesteadny@gmail.com